Header
Carnation Construction
Contact Dave
Carnation
T-03-05 Page loading indicator

Home Site Map - Techniques - Structure -

Columns

Star How to form concrete columns.

Not just for show

You might think that having columns on the outside of a house is just to make the house look great, but the reality is that they are a vital structural component necessary to thermally decouple decks and balconies from the concrete inside the house thermal envelope.  Thermal decoupling is detailed here .

 

Classical Dimensions

I'm using Tuscan style columns.  Tuscan order columns were typically what the Romans used for houses.  I like Tuscan because it is a cleaner look than the more fancy orders and they are also easier to implement.

Tuscan Order columns are plain (non-fluted) and taper for the top 5/7ths.  The diameter at the bottom of the round column is 1/7th of the column height.  The column height includes the base and top, but does not include the Entablature.  The top of the column is 5/6th of the base diameter.

Tuscan Order Tuscan Order 

Tuscan order details

The Entablature (which is the Architrave+Frieze+Cornice) should have a height that is 1.75 times the column base diameter.

Column alignment

It is very important to get the column alignment correct.  The edge of the top of the shaft aligns with the edge of the beam (Architrave) and the edge of the ceiling joists (Frieze).

Column alignment

Column alignment

Columns do not support the ceiling directly.  Instead they support a beam (Architrave) that is what actually supports the ceiling joists (Frieze).  The beam is likely to be somewhere between 8" and 12" tall.

When there are two stories of columns, the alignment must be as per the following drawing.

Column alignment two stories

Supporting decks as they attach to building

The front edge of decks are supported by columns, but visually the deck also needs to be supported as it attaches to the building.  Either this needs to be an "engaged column" (round) or it needs to be a "Pilaster" (rectangular).  Columns are the width of the tapered columns and project out between 5/8 and 3/4 of the column width.  Pilasters are the width of the top of the column and project out from the wall between 1/5 and 1/4 of the column width.  Personally I prefer the look of Pilasters and also they are easiest to implement.

Pilaster deck support

Portico tops

A "Tetrastyle Portico" has four columns.  It was often used by the Greeks and the Etruscans for small structures such as public buildings and amphiprostyles.  The Romans often used the four columned portico for their pseudoperipteral temples like the Temple of Portunus, and for amphiprostyle temples such as the Temple of Venus and Roma, and for the prostyle entrance porticos of large public buildings like the Basilica of Maxentius and Constantine.  Roman provincial capitals also manifested tetrastyle construction, such as the Capitoline Temple in Volubilis.  The North Portico of the White House is perhaps the most notable four-columned portico (ie "Tetrastyle Portico") in the United States.

In a typical Roman temple, the area of the portico top (ie the Entablature and Pediment) is the same as the area of the columns. 

Area of top equals area of columns

Portico single height

 

Measurements

Some interpretation is required for a particular building.  Here are the dimensions I'm using for my house.  I use a spreadsheet to calculate everything and then do sensible rounding of the numbers.

Architectural Dimensions 

 

Round Column Implementation

Columns Main And Bedroom

 

Lots of stacked EPS squares

Get uniform squares, eg 2' square and 6" high.  The squares can be all braced together as a square column.  In each square, cut a circle using a CNC hotwire cutter that is the outside diameter of the column at that height (minus between 1/8" and 1/16" to allow for stucco).  The inside of the concrete tube is formed by a 4" PVC drainpipe.  After the concrete pour the polystyrene is all stripped away.  Stucco is applied to take out the steps (the steps are less than 3/16").  The same technique (using 3/8" thick sheets) can be used to form the bases and tops.

Column Forming With Eps

 

EPS profile cutting

Using the AutoCAD DWG template file from the EPS supplier, make a file with the different diameters.

My EPS supplier can cut the tubes from the 8' CNC cutter into short sections.  They do this by rotating the cut block on the CNC machine.  This is not expensive to do.  For the column stem this will be 6", and for the base and capitals much finer resolution (3/8").

The steps help support the stucco, but the step is only about an 1/8".

 

Cutting sequence for column stem 6" sections

Initially the 8x4x3 ingot is cut with an 8 foot long Carnation Flooring profile.  This reduces the ingot to 8x4x2.

Next the block is cut in half to make a block that is 4x4x2.

The blocks are then cut with one of the CNC profiles.  A 4x4x2 can make 8 of the 6" sections.  Each 4' wide block gives two different section types.

After CNC profile cutting the block is sliced in the other dimension into 6" wide slices.  This provides 8 of each 6" CNC profile, ie enough for 8 columns.  For the main level 16 columns are required so the quantity needs to be doubled.

Here's an example EPS CNC profile...

Column Main Stem Cnc One Example

The following are the different EPS CNC profiles required for one column...

Column Main Stem Cnc 

 

Cutting sequence for 3/8" sections

Initially a 6" thick 8'4' sheet (for Carnation Walling) is cut from the top.  This makes a block that is 8'x4'x2'6".

From the side cut three pieces that are each a 6" thick sheet of dimensions 1'6"x8'.  These will be used for roof insulation.  The resulting block is 2'6"x2'6"x8'.

Cut the block in the other dimension to make eight blocks that are each 2'6x2'6"x1'.  Each block can make 32 of each 3/8" CNC profile type.  At most each profile is used twice on each column, so that means there will be enough items to make 16 columns.

After CNC profile cutting the block is sliced in the other dimension into 3/8" wide slices.

Here's an example EPS CNC profile...

Column Main Base Cnc One Example

The following are the different EPS CNC profiles required for one column...

Column Main Base Cnc

Thermal isolation

This subject is covered in more detail in the section on Balconies .  The upshot is that the concrete of the columns needs to be isolated from the concrete of the building.  Rubber load blocks, as used on some road bridges, are used to achieve this thermal isolation.

Bracing

The 2x4 bracing will be rectangular and not tapered so is easy to implement.

Put vertical L shaped double 2x4s at the corners of the squares.  Screw horizontal bits of 2x4 (with 2x4 padding) between the corner pieces.  Also brace with 2x4s between the columns and back to the wall to keep everything in alignment and avoid getting bowed columns.

 

Rebar etc

The rebar placement is shown in the diagram below together with the rebar stirrups that are every 12" up the column.  The red squares are bridge support load blocks used to provide thermal isolation for the columns.

Column Rebar And Load Blocks Plan

 

Using the EPS offcuts

The EPS cut out from the center can be used to make EPS columns for eg a pagoda or Roman temple in the yard.  A PVC pipe in a hole in the center is used to align the EPS circles to form the column.  The pipe is then filled with bag mixed concrete and a piece of rebar is pushed down into the wet concrete.  Typically a galvanized U is set into the concrete at the top to take a wooden roof beam.  Assuming you get the EPS circles in the right order it will form a Tuscan column that conforms to the correct classical dimensions.  Stucco is added to the outside to finish the column.  The EPS columns are not hugely structural but as it is 15psi EPS with a 4" concrete center they are perfectly capable of supporting a wooden roof and will not get blown over by high winds.

Any unused EPS is broken up into small pieces and used for backfilling geofill.

 

Square Deck Columns

The design

In the design of the main house, the basement level columns are square columns.  This is typical in Vitruvian and Palladian classical architecture.

Square deck columns are formed using 2x6 lumber formwork.  The wooden squares are designed to be removable and reusable.  The squares for the deck pillars are the same size as used for later forming the round columns (although in the case of the round columns they are used to brace the EPS forming).

On either side of the porticos, the deck column forming for the first few feet is a narrower variant because it needs to avoid the forming for the footings and also these pillars do not support much weight.

At the initial foundation forming step we only implement the deck columns up to just above grade level.  They will have rebar protruding about 3 feet from the top, ready for the later step of implementing the columns up to the top of the basement.

Ideally from a visual perspective it would be good to have the deck columns be 2'6" square (rather than the 2' square done with the poured concrete).  It can be decided later (based on visual assessment) whether to increase the size using eg stucco render, stone, or brick cladding.

Deck Column Drawing Plan 

Deck Column Drawing Elevation 

The deck concrete and the deck column concrete is designed to get wet.  It is thermally decoupled and water decoupled from the house concrete (the house concrete is always warm and dry).  The footing concrete for the deck columns is poured directly onto the excavated soil.

For the above grade part of the column there is a 3" drain pipe in the center of the column to drain away water that lands on the deck.  At the bottom of the pipe there is a 90 degree bend that routes the water out the column side to the network of 4" piping that goes to the rain water collection system.  The 3" drain pipe is fitted down the center of low cost 8"x8"x8" concrete blocks.  The concrete block core helps reduce the amount of expensive poured concrete required.

Concrete forming squares for column footing

These have an inside dimension of 3'11" so the outer overlap pieces of 5" wide 2-by are 4'2".  You need 4 squares per column.

Deck Leg Footing Squares Stacked

In the case of 1 out of the 4 squares you need to fit rebar to act as a base for the structural rebar.  Measured on the inside of the square you need just over half inch holes 4.75" in from the inside edge.  On long side pieces these are 1.5" up from the edge and on the 3'11" shorter pieces these are 1" up from the edge (different so that the lateral rebar bypasses the longitudinal rebar).  Fit the rebar and cut it off to the right length (4'2").

Deck Leg Foot Square With Rebar

Concrete forming squares for column shaft

You need to make lots of squares from 5" wide 2x6 lumber.  These have an inside dimension of 2'x2' so the overlap pieces are 2'3".

The 2x6s are cut down on a table saw to be 5" wide so that the edges are not rounded.  Because so many are needed and it is important to achieve dimensional consistency, for the 2'x2' squares, use a jig with a 2'x2' square of 2x4 in the middle and cross pieces of 2x4 to hold it square and support the edges of the square being assembled.  Here's the jig...

Deck Leg Jig

Start by using clamps to accurately position the pieces of the square.  Use a rubber mallet to get everything accurately positioned and aligned.

Clamps On Deck Leg Jig 

The squares are just screwed together without glue so they can be easily stripped after the concrete pour.  Use exterior 3" screws as you want them to be strong and you will be able to reuse them.  Use two screws per corner located 1.25" from each edge.  Try to be consistent in the wood you use because the pattern in the concrete will be left after the wood forming is removed.  The fashionable look is called "board formed concrete".  I used wood cut on my sawmill with a rough sawn finish to get the consistent look I want.  Here's a square assembled on the jig...

Deck Leg Piece On Jig

Jig With Clamps Column Squares 

Here's a bunch of squares stacked up ready to be used...

Squares For Deck Column 

The first square at the bottom of the column shaft is fitted with rebar to accurately position the structural rebar.  It also helps align the concrete blocks in the right location.  The just over half inch holes are 8" from the inside edge of the wooden square.  In the center (with some very slight flexing) it can accommodate a concrete block that is 7-5/8" square.

Deck Leg Square With Rebar

(In the picture below you will also see some of the rectangles used in the portico variant of the deck columns (see later).)

Deck Column Rect With Rebar

Starting a deck column

The locations of the deck columns are as per your CAD drawings.  Measure relative to the batterboard strings.  You may have to extrapolate the string locations a bit if the columns are outside the area covered by the batterboards.  Set additional strings if you need them.  Use a plumb-bob down from the strings to determine the position of the footing squares at the bottom of the excavation.

The excavated area of undisturbed soil under the footing for the column needs to be excavated approximately flat and level.  Place one of the footing square wooden rectangles on the ground.  Use a spirit level and a trowel to get it level.  Place a 12"x12" paving slab in the center and get it level using the spirit level and trowel.  Soil that is not under the wooden rectangle or the paving slab does not need to be particularly flat (it can even have big holes where a rock was removed).  Accurately position the wooden footing square and the paving slab, and with shims if necessary, get them both level.

Deck Column Get Level Base

The second wood square is the one with the rebar fitted (rebar near the bottom edge).

Deck Leg Two Rect Side

Backfill with soil around the footing up to a height of about 4" (ie just short of the top of the first square).  This will hold the bottom wooden square in the right location.

Deck Leg Two Rect Side

Complete forming of deck column footing

Add the other 2 wooden rectangles for the footing, making a total of 4.  Weigh down the corners to keep everything in place.

Weigh Down Deck Leg Footing Forming 

Backfill with non-organic soil to the top round the outside to fix the location and avoid lateral movement.

Filled Around Deck Leg Footings 

Across the top of the footing forming go some 2'3" long horizontal 5" wide 2x6 lumber to reduce the size down to the smaller wooden rectangles used for the stem of the column.  The position of this needs to be set accurately from the batterboard strings to correspond with the position of the column stem (inside dimension).  To avoid cumulative error, do not just measure relative to the footing rectangle.

Don't fit all the fill-in horizontal lumber until the structural rebar has been fitted (see later), although it can be useful to rest it in place to stop soil falling into the footing.

Start forming column stem

Fit the first of the column stem lumber squares.  This first one has the composite rebar that holds the first of the column stirrups.  Measure relative to the batterboard strings to accurately set the position of the column stem square.  To avoid cumulative errors, do not just measure from the edge of the footing squares.  Screw on some 1.5"x1.5" batons to hold the column stem square in the right place.  The batons have holes in the side and use these to screw to the column stem square.

Deck Leg With First Column Square Side

Deck Leg With First Column Square

Get the top of the first column stem square exactly level by if necessary adjusting the shims under the column footing squares.

Site Deck Legs West Started

Concrete block center

Start building up a stack of concrete blocks in the center on the paving slab.  They are glued using PL-Premium adhesive.  Get them vertical using a spirit level (although exact vertical accuracy is not that important).  The concrete blocks up to slab height do not have a drainpipe in the center.  They are purely to reduce the amount of expensive poured concrete required.

Deck Column Base Of Stem

Deck Leg With Starter Blocks

Add more column stem lumber squares

Place stem forming concrete squares up to a height of just above excavation level.  Alternate where the overlap edges of the wooden squares are.  Get them about right in terms of alignment.  Even though you are not yet rigidly fixing the squares in the final position, the position of the squares should be placed relative to the batterboard strings rather than trying to make the column vertical using a spirit level as this avoids cumulative errors.  The hope though is that a spirit level would show that the column is vertical.

Mease With Tee From Strings

Be conscious that at some point you need to fit the vertical composite rebar (that has a bend in the end).  Use a trial piece of vertical rebar with a cut turn end to make sure you can still get it in.  In practice you will find you can still get the rebar in even with the forming up to grade level.

Deck Column Stem Temp

Site First Deck Leg Formed

Use horizontal spacer lumber between columns

Now is a good time to make the horizontal lumber pieces that will be used to brace the columns to each other.  The length is the pitch between columns as given by your CAD drawings.  If you find that the distance between implemented columns is not correct then you must immediately find out what is wrong and correct the problem.

Start by picking a reference column.  It is best if the one chosen is closest to the batterboard strings so that its position can be more accurately set.  Once its position is accurately set, use temporary bracing from eg the batterboards to ensure it does not move.

Brace To Reference Column

The horizontal spacing lumber has spacers on the end to avoid the vertical batons that will be on the columns.  The spacer blocks are centered at 1" and 9" from the end.  The holes need to be large enough to clear the 6" screws that will be used.

Column Spacer Spacers

Lots Of Inter Column Wood Spacers

Columns Braced Right Distance Apart

Site Colmn Location Spacers

Spacers Ahead Of Column Squares 

Add more concrete blocks

Use PL-Premium adhesive between the blocks.  Set each block's position from the inside edge of the column stem squares using a spacer stick that is 8-1/8" long.  Only add enough blocks to get to where the drain pipe will exit.

Spacer For Concrete Block Center

Drain pipe exit

While adding the concrete blocks, when you get to about 8" below grade level, you need to use a concrete block with the side cut out.  It needs to be arranged such that the horizontal drain pipe from the column is just below grade so that it will not be visible.  Use a circular saw with a carbide grinder wheel to cut out the side of a concrete block with enough clearance for a 3" to 4" 90 degree bend.

Concrete Block Cut For Pipe Exit

Pvc Bend 4in To 3in  PVC Bend 4in to 3in

The open side of the block faces towards the downhill corner of the site.  These will all connect up to take water to your rain water collection tank.

Mark on the column stem squares where the horizontal 4" drain pipe will exit and cut a hole with a jig saw.  Make the hole size to allow for a collar piece (about 4-3/8" outside diameter).

Deck Leg With Pipe Out The Side

Do not actually fix the pipe in place yet because it would stop you adding rebar stirrups.

Note that the 3"-to-4" bend is designed for thick wall PVC pipe so you will need to use a collar fitting (pipe joiner) to adapt it to the thinner wall PVC pipe.

Add one more concrete block (not cut) to complete the initial stack of concrete blocks to just above grade level.  You will fill the wooden column with concrete on the initial pour to half way up this last concrete block such that the block will form a peg that sticks up into the next concrete pour to mechanically key it together across a cold joint.

Site Deck Columns Five Started

Site Deck Leg Spacers

Implement critical bits of horizontal drainage pipes

In order to make sure you get the pipe exits from the columns on the correct side it is important that you fully know how all the pipes will connect up.  You should draw all the pipes on your AutoCAD drawing.  Also you should implement any bits of horizontal piping that you feel are critical to your understanding of how the pipes will be implemented.  Things like the routing of the sewer pipe will have a higher priority than the drainage pipes so you also need to know the routing of the sewer pipes.

Add structural rebar and stirrups

Cut the short ends of the half inch rebar type that has bends on the bottom ends to a length (from the outside of the long leg) of 1'8".  The long legs are cut to be just over 3 foot longer than the height of the first concrete pour.  Add the vertical rebar to the column.  There is vertical rebar at the corners and also on the edges that are adjacent to other columns.  The short tails of the rebar for the middle edge rebar can be slightly angled to get them to fit.  Add deck column stirrups by dropping them down over the top of the vertical rebar.  The stirrups are every 12" and the bottom stirrup rests on the positioning rebar that was fitted to the first wooden stem square.

Deck Column Drawing Plan

Deck Column Drawing Elevation

In the footings, add additional lengths of straight rebar as per the drawing.

 

Add vertical batons

The vertical batons are pieces of 1.5"x1.5" lumber.  The reason these are added as a fairly last step is that in the case of fresh cut lumber it will shrink across the grain over time and if the batons were added to early then you would get gaps between the squares.  Use 8 batons per column.  Make them long enough to include one square above final grade height.  As you screw them on, be conscious of getting the position of the squares accurately set relative to the batterboard strings.  Because of the variation in wood thickness, not all screws will be fully tightened.

Screw Batons Top And Bottom

 

Deck column for portico

The deck columns that are on either side of the porticos are a slight variant on a regular deck column because there is not as much room given the forming for the wall footings.  This is not a problem because these columns do not carry as much load.

The wooden framing for these column footings have an inside dimension of 2'5"x3'11".  There are only 3 of these footing rectangles in the stack.

Portico Deck Column Stem Base 

The second rectangle has two pieces of rebar fitted (4.75" from the inside edge) to form a base for the structural rebar.

Portico Deck Leg Rebar Across 

The house peripheral perforated drain pipe goes round the outside of the portico deck leg footing so therefore it is crushed rock that is used to backfill behind the wooden forming rectangles (rather than soil).  Get the footing rectangles exactly horizontal using shims and/or a trowel on the excavated soil. 

Portico Deck Leg With Cross Rebar

Also get a paving slab seated level (the photo above does not yet have the paving slab in the right location).

Screw on two pieces of 5" wide lumber to do the transition from the footing to the thinner column stem.  Use a plumb-bob from the batterboard strings to accurately set the position so it matches your AutoCAD drawing.

Portico Deck Column Transition To Stem 

The forming for the portico deck columns (up until slab height) is done using wooden rectangles with an inside dimension of 1' 5-1/2" x 2'.  As with all other deck forming they are 2x6" lumber cut to a width of 5".  The first of the rectangles used for the column stem has support rebar fitted.  This is arranged to accommodate a concrete block (against the inside edge) that is 7-5/8" square.

Deck Leg Portico Rect With Rebar 

On the inside, the stem rectangles are flush with the footing rectangles and the gap is filled in with a 2' length of 1.5"x1.5" lumber.

Portico Deck Column Stem Base And Blocks 

Portico Deck Column Stem Temp 

Don't yet screw on the extra bits of lumber that form the top of the footing, but you can rest them in place to stop soil falling into the footing.

Deck Leg Portico Inside 

Deck Leg Portico Outside 

Site Deck Legs Started 

 

Concrete pour

To pour an approximately 8 foot high column (with its footings) it takes about 2 cubic yards of concrete.

 


 

*